Nacra 17 Class updates Elevator & Rudder Rake system
Interesting changes for the current Olympic Multihull, we hope Nacra not to kill sailors with costs on these updates for new winglets / elevators and new rudder rake system, which looks pretty clever and simple.
Below detailed report by Nacra 17 Class Assoc
Nacra 17 Introduces Small Changes to Rudder Systems for Paris Quadrennial
Since the Tokyo Olympics, Nacra 17 has adopted two small changes to the rudder systems to help improve safety and performance. Both changes will be incorporated by the fleet over the winter months, between the 2021 World Championship in Oman (November) and the 2022 Princess Sofia Trophy Regatta (March).
Uptated Elevator
The first change is to adopt an updated elevator, seen above. (blue is old, green is new)
The two elevators are almost identical in overall size. The new (green) elevator has blunted edges and a blunter central ‘torpedo’, along with being slightly offset to leeward. The blunting is aimed at decreasing the chances of cuts should sailors fall into the water and be struck by the elevator. The offsetting is to incrementally reduce the likelihood of being struck by the elevator.
In testing, these elevators were found to perform the same way the current elevators perform, with sailors having difficulty feeling any difference at all. The performance of the boat seemed unaffected during testing.
Adjustable Rudder Rake
The second change is an adjustable rudder rake system. The existing rudder rake is adjustable, but the system and class rules do not allow for it to be adjusted during racing. Limiting the rudder rake during racing kept the boat simpler, but limited the performance of the boat as a compromise between optimal upwind settings and downwind setting was required. Often, this compromise, or an increase in wind during a race, forced teams to sail downwind with too much lift, making sailing very challenging and less safe than what is possible.
The change is simply a new top gudgeon and two pulley’s added to the transom. The pulleys lead the control lines forward for the crew to adjust. Further pulleys and cleats may be added by the teams, without limit except for where on the deck they may be mounted, so teams can rig the control lines as they wish.
The update also increases slightly the range of adjustment offered to the sailors, going from 3.5 degrees total span to 4.5 degrees total span.
The lack of limitation placed on the sailors also, intentionally, will allow them to incorporate differential rudder rake so the windward and leeward rudders may not be at the same angle as each other. While technically this was possible in the previous set up, teams had to tack and gybe, and would aim for a common rake between the sides.
A differential rake will allow the windward elevator to have negative lift while the leeward elevator has positive lift, increasing the power available to the sailors marginally. Overall, this should help the boat foil upwind in a wider variety of conditions, allow the boat to get foiling more easily, and do both without risking a rise in the optimum crew weight.
There are also two safety improvements the system should offer.
Teams should be able to sail downwind with the amount of rudder rake they prefer, instead of hoping to survive the downwind with the rudder rake optimized for the upwind.
If a sailor falls into the water and hits the rudder or elevator, as has occurred from time to time, if the system is not at maximum lift then the spring within the system may give slightly on impact, somewhat decreasing the point loads on the sailor at impact. Note, this is a theoretical gain, and has not been tested.
No further changes are planned for the Nacra 17 until the conclusion of the 2024 Paris Olympics.
